After finishing the novel of Eleanor and Park I noticed that it portrayed a lot of good YA
literature themes such as the following:
Teen love, family issues, bullying, gender/cultural
conflicts along with many others. This may sound cliché, but in order for a
book to be considered a successful YA book it must contain a good portion of
these themes. I was really impressed with how the author incorporated character
development in this novel because it was done like no other book I had read. In
most YA literature when the teens are falling for each other it takes no time
for each of them to say those three little words. . . “I love you.” However, in
this book we had the case where Eleanor who wouldn't confess her to love Park
as he had done for her, but as the book continues we get to see the development
in Eleanor’s self-worth and confidence. The post card that contained three
words to Park has been an implication of her expressing her love. This
character development then relates very well with the themes of the novel
because it exploits the characters personalities. Eleanor’s family issues can
make the argument as to why her self-confidence is low. Cultural conflict such
as needing to be “skinny, wear new clothes, etc” can be the argument as to why
the kids who don’t fit this persona are bullied. These themes overall did a
great job in portraying teen life. The only main critique I could give on this
book is that I felt the family issues were too cliché for each party. We have
all seen the poor guy or girl end up with the wealthy significant other. I
would have been more intrigued if Eleanor had come from a more wealthy family
such as Park had, this could have made for a new type of YA literature theme
and created different options for the book to have gone. This being said I just
think this book fell too much into the gender stereotype of the poor girl
getting the wealthy guy; this theme occurs in the movies Cinderella, Sixteen
Candles, Maid in Manhattan along with many others. Other than this critique I believe
that this book was very well done and great read. This text is clearly
positioning towards adolescents because it is including every day issues that
teens endure. This makes for a teen to be keen into reading this book because
they can relate to it. Adolescence is not an easy time in life for people; you
endure lots of changes and start facing day to day issues that can cause
immense pain. This text is portraying just that, it is showing how social
status, looks, athletic skill and other factors can have a huge impact on your
teen years. This appeals to teens because everything that they are reading is
what they are living. It is something they can relate too and even has the
possibilities of helping them cope with their problems or change their
behaviors (positively or negatively). There is so much good that comes out of
teens reading these types of YA literature which is why I would give this novel
a solid B+/A- grade. It shows the actual real life problems, situations and day
to day issues that teens endure and is an easy text to connect with.
No comments:
Post a Comment